✂️ The Vertical Bisector — Cutting a Triangle in Half

Math Circle Lecture  |  Ages 13–15  |  Duration: 90 minutes  |  Topics: Geometry, Area, Similar Triangles, Trigonometry, Calculus (optional)


The Puzzle

Triangle $ABC$ has base $AB = 70$ cm, left side $AC = 65$ cm, and right side $BC = 75$ cm. Find the position and length of a line perpendicular to the base $AB$ that divides the triangle into two regions of equal area.

Before we dive in, let's pause: Does such a line always exist? Could there be more than one?

70 65 75 h = 60 PQ = 20√7 1050 1050 A B C F P Q

Step 0 — Setting the Stage (15 min)

Finding the Height

We need the height from $C$ down to base $AB$. Let $F$ be the foot of that altitude.

Using Heron's Formula:

Semi-perimeter:

$$s = \frac{70 + 65 + 75}{2} = 105$$

Area:

$$\text{Area} = \sqrt{s(s-a)(s-b)(s-c)} = \sqrt{105 \times 35 \times 40 \times 30}$$
StepComputationValue
$105 \times 35$$3{,}675$
$40 \times 30$$1{,}200$
Product$3{,}675 \times 1{,}200$$4{,}410{,}000$
Square root$\sqrt{4{,}410{,}000}$$\mathbf{2{,}100}$
$$\text{Area} = 2{,}100 \text{ cm}^2$$

Now the height:

$$h = \frac{2 \times \text{Area}}{AB} = \frac{2 \times 2{,}100}{70} = 60 \text{ cm}$$

Locating the Altitude Foot

Where does the altitude meet $AB$? Using the Pythagorean theorem in sub-triangle $AFC$:

$$AF^2 + h^2 = AC^2 \implies AF^2 = 65^2 - 60^2 = 4{,}225 - 3{,}600 = 625$$ $$AF = 25 \text{ cm}$$

Check: $FB = 70 - 25 = 45$, and $45^2 + 60^2 = 2{,}025 + 3{,}600 = 5{,}625 = 75^2$ ✓

Coordinate Setup

PointCoordinates
$A$$(0,\; 0)$
$B$$(70,\; 0)$
$C$$(25,\; 60)$
$F$ (altitude foot)$(25,\; 0)$

Step 1 — The Key Insight (10 min)

Which Side Does the Line Cross?

Our vertical line sits at some position $x = d$ on the base. But which slanted side does it meet — $AC$ or $BC$?

The altitude at $F$ splits the triangle into two parts:

Sub-triangleBaseHeightArea
Left ($AFC$)$AF = 25$$60$$750$
Right ($FBC$)$FB = 45$$60$$1{,}350$
Total$2{,}100$ ✓

Half the total area is $\mathbf{1{,}050}$.

Key observation: Since $750 < 1{,}050 < 1{,}350$, the bisecting line must sit between $F$ and $B$ — between positions 25 and 70 on the base. It crosses side $BC$.

Why Not on the Left Side?

If the line were at $d \leq 25$, the left region would be a right triangle with legs $d$ and $\tfrac{12d}{5}$:

$$\text{Area} = \frac{6d^2}{5}$$

Setting this to $1{,}050$ gives $d = 5\sqrt{35} \approx 29.6$, which is greater than 25. Contradiction!

No solution on the left side. The entire left sub-triangle ($750$ cm²) isn't enough to make half the total area.

Solution 1 — Direct Area Computation Elementary

The Right Triangle Insight

For $25 < d < 70$, the vertical line at $x = d$ creates a right triangle on the right with vertices $P(d,\,0)$, $B(70,\,0)$, and $Q$ on side $BC$.

Height at position $d$: Side $BC$ descends from $C(25, 60)$ to $B(70, 0)$. Its slope is:

$$\text{slope of } BC = \frac{60 - 0}{25 - 70} = -\frac{4}{3}$$

At horizontal distance $(70 - d)$ from $B$, the height is:

$$PQ = \frac{4}{3}(70 - d)$$

Setting Up the Equation

Right triangle $BPQ$ has:

$$\text{Area}(\triangle BPQ) = \frac{1}{2}(70 - d) \cdot \frac{4}{3}(70 - d) = \frac{2}{3}(70 - d)^2$$

Set equal to half the total area:

$$\frac{2}{3}(70 - d)^2 = 1{,}050$$ $$(70 - d)^2 = 1{,}575$$ $$70 - d = \sqrt{1{,}575} = \sqrt{225 \times 7} = 15\sqrt{7}$$
$$d = 70 - 15\sqrt{7} \approx 30.31 \text{ cm from } A$$

The Length of the Bisecting Line

$$PQ = \frac{4}{3}(70 - d) = \frac{4}{3} \times 15\sqrt{7} = 20\sqrt{7} \approx 52.92 \text{ cm}$$

Verification: $\frac{1}{2}(15\sqrt{7})(20\sqrt{7}) = \frac{1}{2} \times 300 \times 7 = 1{,}050$ ✓


Solution 2 — Similar Triangles Elegant

This is the most beautiful elementary approach.

The Key Similarity

Consider the right triangle $BFC$ (from the altitude):

Now consider our right triangle $BPQ$ (the cut piece):

By AA similarity: $\triangle BPQ \sim \triangle BFC$

The scale factor is:

$$k = \frac{BP}{BF} = \frac{70 - d}{45}$$

Area Ratio

Areas scale as the square of the linear ratio:

$$\frac{\text{Area}(\triangle BPQ)}{\text{Area}(\triangle BFC)} = k^2$$ $$\frac{1{,}050}{1{,}350} = k^2 \implies k^2 = \frac{7}{9} \implies k = \frac{\sqrt{7}}{3}$$

Position and Length

$$\frac{70 - d}{45} = \frac{\sqrt{7}}{3} \implies 70 - d = 15\sqrt{7} \implies d = 70 - 15\sqrt{7}$$ $$\frac{PQ}{FC} = k \implies PQ = 60 \times \frac{\sqrt{7}}{3} = 20\sqrt{7}$$
Bonus insight: The scale factor $k = \sqrt{7}/3 \approx 0.882$ means the cut triangle is about 88% the linear size of the full right sub-triangle.

Solution 3 — Trigonometric Approach Trig

Finding Angle $B$

Using the Law of Cosines:

$$\cos B = \frac{AB^2 + BC^2 - AC^2}{2 \cdot AB \cdot BC} = \frac{4{,}900 + 5{,}625 - 4{,}225}{10{,}500} = \frac{6{,}300}{10{,}500} = \frac{3}{5}$$

So $\cos B = \frac{3}{5}$ and $\sin B = \frac{4}{5}$. A 3-4-5 angle!

Working in Triangle $BPQ$

In the right triangle $BPQ$, the hypotenuse $BQ$ lies along side $BC$:

$$BP = BQ\cos B = \tfrac{3}{5}\,BQ \qquad\qquad PQ = BQ\sin B = \tfrac{4}{5}\,BQ$$

Area via the Double-Angle Formula

$$\text{Area}(\triangle BPQ) = \frac{1}{2} \cdot BP \cdot PQ = \frac{1}{2}\,BQ^2\sin B\cos B = \frac{1}{4}\,BQ^2\sin(2B)$$

We need $\sin(2B)$:

$$\sin(2B) = 2\sin B\cos B = 2 \times \frac{4}{5} \times \frac{3}{5} = \frac{24}{25}$$

Setting the area to $1{,}050$:

$$\frac{1}{4} \cdot BQ^2 \cdot \frac{24}{25} = 1{,}050 \implies \frac{6}{25}\,BQ^2 = 1{,}050 \implies BQ^2 = 4{,}375$$ $$BQ = \sqrt{4{,}375} = \sqrt{625 \times 7} = 25\sqrt{7}$$

Extracting Position and Length

$$BP = \frac{3}{5} \times 25\sqrt{7} = 15\sqrt{7} \implies d = 70 - 15\sqrt{7}$$ $$PQ = \frac{4}{5} \times 25\sqrt{7} = 20\sqrt{7}$$
Extra finding: The bisecting line meets $BC$ at a point $Q$ that is $BQ = 25\sqrt{7} \approx 66.14$ cm from $B$ — about 88% of the way along $BC$ (total length 75).

Solution 4 — Calculus: Integration Advanced

For students who know integration, we can compute the area to the left of $x = d$ directly.

The Triangle's Height Function

At position $x$, the triangle's height above the base is:

$$y(x) = \begin{cases} \dfrac{12x}{5} & 0 \leq x \leq 25 \quad \text{(along side } AC\text{)} \\[8pt] \dfrac{4(70 - x)}{3} & 25 \leq x \leq 70 \quad \text{(along side } BC\text{)} \end{cases}$$

Area to the Left of $x = d$  (for $d > 25$)

$$A(d) = \int_0^{25} \frac{12x}{5}\,dx \;+\; \int_{25}^{d} \frac{4(70 - x)}{3}\,dx$$

First integral:

$$\int_0^{25} \frac{12x}{5}\,dx = \frac{6}{5}\,x^2\Big|_0^{25} = \frac{6}{5}(625) = 750$$

(The area of sub-triangle $AFC$ — no surprise!)

Second integral:

$$\int_{25}^{d} \frac{4(70 - x)}{3}\,dx = \frac{4}{3}\left[70x - \frac{x^2}{2}\right]_{25}^{d} = \frac{4}{3}\!\left[\!\left(70d - \frac{d^2}{2}\right) - 1{,}437.5\right]$$

Setting $A(d) = 1{,}050$

$$750 + \frac{4}{3}\!\left(70d - \frac{d^2}{2} - 1{,}437.5\right) = 1{,}050$$

Simplifying step by step:

$$70d - \frac{d^2}{2} - 1{,}437.5 = 225$$ $$d^2 - 140d + 3{,}325 = 0$$

By the quadratic formula:

$$d = \frac{140 \pm \sqrt{19{,}600 - 13{,}300}}{2} = \frac{140 \pm \sqrt{6{,}300}}{2} = \frac{140 \pm 30\sqrt{7}}{2} = 70 \pm 15\sqrt{7}$$

Since $d < 70$:

$$d = 70 - 15\sqrt{7} \approx 30.31 \text{ cm}$$

The other root $d = 70 + 15\sqrt{7} \approx 109.7$ lies outside the triangle — our quadratic "remembers" that the parabolic area function continues beyond the triangle's boundary.


Summary — The Answer

QuantityExact ValueApproximate
Position from $A$$70 - 15\sqrt{7}$ cm$30.31$ cm
Position from $B$$15\sqrt{7}$ cm$39.69$ cm
Length of line $PQ$$20\sqrt{7}$ cm$52.92$ cm
Distance $BQ$ along $BC$$25\sqrt{7}$ cm$66.14$ cm

Why Four Solutions?

Each approach illuminates a different facet of the problem:

MethodKey IdeaPrerequisites
1 Direct computationHeight = slope × distanceRise/run, Pythagorean theorem
2 Similar trianglesAreas scale as $k^2$AA similarity, ratios
3 TrigonometryUse $\angle B$ via cosine ruleLaw of Cosines, double-angle
4 IntegrationArea = integral of heightDefinite integrals, quadratic formula

All four arrive at the exact same answer — which is reassuring, and beautiful.


Extensions & Challenge Problems 🧩

1. The General Ratio

Instead of bisecting the area, cut off a fraction $r$ of the total area on the right. Show that:

$$70 - d = \sqrt{3{,}150\,r} \qquad\text{and}\qquad PQ = \frac{4}{3}\sqrt{3{,}150\,r}$$
Hint

Start from $\frac{2}{3}(70 - d)^2 = 2{,}100\,r$ and solve for $(70-d)$.

2. Bisecting from the Left

What if the apex $C$ were at $x = 50$ instead of $x = 25$? Now the larger sub-triangle is on the left, and the bisecting line might cross side $AC$ instead. Work it out!

3. Impossible Bisection?

Is there a triangle where no perpendicular-to-base line can bisect the area? Think about what happens when the apex is directly above one endpoint of the base…

Discussion

If $C$ is above $A$ (i.e., $AF = 0$), then the entire triangle lies on the right side of the altitude. A vertical line can still bisect it — the region to the left is always a right triangle. The equation $\frac{2}{3}(70 - d)^2 = 1050$ always has a solution in $(0, 70)$. So it's always possible! Every triangle can be bisected by a line perpendicular to any chosen base.

4. Three Equal Parts

Find two vertical lines that divide our triangle into three regions of equal area ($700$ cm² each). Determine both positions.

Hint

The rightmost cut creates a right triangle of area $700$. The middle cut creates a region of area $700$ between the two cuts. Think carefully about whether both cuts are to the right of $F$, or one is to the left.


Math Circle Lecture — Geometry & Area Bisection